Best Substitute for Cream of Chicken Soup: 7 Options

Ever found yourself in the middle of cooking, only to realize you’re out of cream of mushroom soup? Don’t worry, you’re not alone. This kitchen staple has saved countless meals, but what if I told you there are plenty of options that can work just as well as a substitute for cream of chicken soup, if not better?

Let’s face it, sometimes that can of condensed soup just doesn’t cut it. Maybe you’re seeking more than just convenience and want a fresher taste. Perhaps you’re trying to avoid the extra sodium and preservatives. You’ll be surprised at how easy it is to whip up a substitute for cream of mushroom soup that’ll have your taste buds dancing.

Jump to:

• What is Chicken Of Mushroom Soup?
• 3 Best Cream of Chicken Soup Substitutes
• 4 Other Cream of Chicken Soup Substitutes To Try
• FAQs
• Conclusion
• Recipe

What is Chicken Of Mushroom Soup?

Chicken of Mushroom Soup is a playful, yet delicious twist on the classic Chicken and Mushroom Soup. Making a homemade chicken soup recipe allows you to avoid preservatives and artificial ingredients typically found in store-bought options.

It's a comforting dish where chicken and mushrooms are combined in a flavorful broth, often with a creamy base. The name is a humorous play on "Cream of Mushroom Soup," but this version includes tender pieces of chicken along with the earthy mushrooms.

The soup typically starts with sautéing onions, garlic, and mushrooms in butter, followed by adding chunks of chicken, broth, and seasonings. Some recipes also incorporate cream or milk to give the soup a rich, velvety texture. It's a hearty, warming dish perfect for cool weather or when you're craving something comforting.

If you're interested in trying or making this soup, think of it as a heartier version of Cream of Mushroom Soup with the added protein and flavor of chicken.

3 Best Cream of Chicken Soup Substitutes

When it comes to getting that flavor just right, there are certain alternatives that suit the job perfectly! Making a homemade chicken soup recipe is a fantastic alternative to store-bought options.

By using ingredients like butter, flour, broth, and heavy cream, you can achieve a rich flavor and desired consistency without the preservatives and artificial ingredients typically found in commercial products.

This method not only ensures a healthier option but also allows you to control the quality and taste of your soup. See some options listed below:

1. Condensed Chicken Broth

Let's start with something you probably already have in your pantry. Condensed chicken broth can be a lifesaver when you're in a pinch. It's not an exact match for cream of mushroom soup, but it can work wonders in many recipes as a substitute for cream of mushroom soup.

To use condensed chicken broth as a substitute, simply use it in a 1:1 ratio. However, keep in mind that it won't have the same creamy texture or mushroom flavor. To remedy this, try adding a bit of milk or cream and some finely chopped mushrooms if you have them on hand.

Best for: Condensed chicken broth makes an excellent substitute for cream of chicken soup because it's flavorful and can be thickened easily, perfect for homemade pesto or a chicken casserole like chicken pot pie or creamy pasta dishes.

2. Broth + Cornstarch or Flour

If you're looking for a substitute that's a bit closer to the real deal, try combining broth with a thickening agent like cornstarch or flour. This method gives you more control over the consistency of your substitute.

Best for: Mixing broth with cornstarch or flour is a thick, flavorful substitute for cream of chicken soup and is ideal for recipes like green bean casseroles, chicken casseroles, creamy soups, or gravies.

3. Creamy Soups

These canned soups have the same consistency as the cream of chicken, giving your recipe the creaminess it needs, and can work as a chicken soup substitute in most recipes.

Also, when you use any creamy soup to substitute cream of chicken soup, you won't need to adjust the measurement. Add the same amount of the cream soup as the recipe calls for chicken soup.

Best for: Creamy soups work well as a substitute for cream of chicken soup in recipes such as casseroles, pot pies, chicken and rice dishes, and slow-cooker recipes.

Cream of Mushroom Soup

This ingredient might not be as savory and salty as cream of chicken, but it has a strong earthy, umami flavor that can elevate your recipe's taste and aroma.

Hence, cream of mushroom soup isn't just a vegan and vegetarian substitute for cream of chicken soup. It's also ideal for those looking for an ingredient that can add a unique twist to their recipes without affecting the balance of flavor.

However, most cream of mushroom soup products aren't gluten-free because they contain wheat flour.

Best for: Cream of mushroom soup makes a great cream of chicken soup substitute, offering a savory, earthy flavor and creamy texture in casseroles, pasta bakes, or chicken pot pie.

Cream of Potato Soup

Believe it or not, cream of potato soup can be a great substitute for cream of mushroom soup in many recipes. It provides a similar creamy texture and can be easily flavored to mimic mushroom soup.

Best for: Cream of potato soup is a great cream of chicken soup substitute, providing a creamy texture and mild flavor in casseroles, chowders, or baked chicken dishes.

Cream of Celery Soup

Cream of celery soup is another excellent substitute for cream of mushroom soup. It has a mild flavor that won't overpower your dish but still provides that creamy texture you're looking for.

Best for: Cream of celery soup makes a great cream of chicken soup substitute, offering a mild, savory flavor and creamy texture in casseroles, chicken pot pie, or pasta dishes.

Cream of Broccoli Soup

For a nutrient-packed substitute, try cream of broccoli soup. It's a great way to sneak in some extra veggies while still getting that creamy texture you need.

Best for: Cream of broccoli soup makes a great cream of chicken soup substitute, providing a rich, creamy texture with a vegetal flavor and is perfect in quiches, savory pies, or rice dishes.

Cream of Bacon Soup

Now, for something a little indulgent - cream of bacon soup. This substitute adds a smoky, savory flavor that can take your dish to the next level.

Best for: Cream of bacon soup is a great cream of chicken soup substitute, adding a smoky, savory depth and creamy texture in potato dishes, savory pot pies, pasta casseroles, or as a dip base.

Cream of Shrimp Soup

For seafood lovers, cream of shrimp soup can be a delightful substitute for cream of mushroom soup. It adds a touch of elegance to your dishes and works particularly well in seafood-based recipes. This is also a great way to spice up your shrimp recipes.

I choose this option each time I have pescatarian guests and want to serve them dishes popular for their rich chicken taste. We all agree that we enjoy surprising our guests with unique dishes or common dishes with a bit of a twist we prepare for them.

Best for: Cream of shrimp soup makes a great cream of chicken soup substitute in seafood chowders, pasta dishes, or rice casseroles.

4 Other Cream of Chicken Soup Substitutes To Try

A few recipes list cream of chicken soup mainly for thickening purposes and binding ingredients instead of adding chicken flavor to the dish. While making sure you use a substitute that can help you achieve the right creamy texture, you have to choose an ingredient that won't affect the balance of flavor.

With that in mind, here are easily accessible and affordable options that I highly recommend:

1. Beurre Manié

Beurre manié is a fancy French term for a simple mixture of equal parts flour and softened butter. It's a great way to thicken soups and sauces without the risk of lumps.

To use beurre manié as a substitute for cream of mushroom soup:

1. Mix 2 tablespoons of softened butter with 2 tablespoons of flour until it forms a paste.
2. Whisk this mixture into 1 cup of hot chicken or vegetable broth.
3. Simmer until thickened, then add seasoning to taste.

This substitute works well in recipes where you want to control the thickness of your sauce or soup.

Best for: Beurre manié makes an excellent substitute for cream of chicken soup by adding creamy thickness without altering flavor, perfect for enhancing chicken pot pie or creamy chicken and rice dishes.

2. Heavy Cream

Sometimes, simplicity is key. Heavy cream can be a great substitute for cream of mushroom soup when you're looking for richness without the mushroom flavor.

To use heavy cream as a substitute, use a 1:1 ratio.

Best for: Heavy cream makes an excellent stand-in for cream of chicken soup by adding richness and smooth texture, ideal for recipes like creamy chicken pasta or chicken casseroles.

3. Sour Cream

Sour cream can be a tangy, creamy substitute for cream of mushroom soup. It adds richness and a slight tang that can brighten up many dishes.

To use sour cream as a substitute:

1. Mix 1 cup of sour cream with ¼ cup of chicken or vegetable broth to thin it out.
2. If you need it thicker, whisk in 1 tablespoon of flour.
3. Season with salt, pepper, and any herbs you like.

Best for: Sour cream makes a great alternative for cream of chicken soup by adding tangy richness and creamy texture, perfect for dishes like chicken enchiladas or creamy chicken casseroles.

4. Unflavored or Plain Greek Yogurt

For a healthier alternative, try using Greek yogurt as a substitute for cream of mushroom soup. It's high in protein and gives a nice creamy texture to your dishes.

To use Greek yogurt as a substitute:

1. Mix 1 cup of Greek yogurt with ¼ cup of chicken or vegetable broth.
2. If you need it thicker, strain the yogurt through a cheesecloth before mixing.
3. Season with salt, pepper, and any herbs you like.

Best for: Unflavored or plain Greek yogurt makes an excellent substitute for cream of chicken soup by adding creaminess with a slight tang, ideal for recipes like chicken stroganoff or chicken pot pie.

Also read: Best Greek Yogurt Substitutes for every recipe need.

Conclusion

As we've explored, there's a whole world of options when it comes to finding chicken substitutes. Whether you're dealing with dietary restrictions, trying to eat healthier, or just want to experiment with new flavors, these alternatives can make a world of difference.

From the simplicity of condensed chicken broth to the indulgence of homemade cream of bacon soup, each substitute brings its own unique flavor profile to the table. And let's not forget the healthier options like Greek yogurt or the versatility of a simple beurre manié. Whatever you choose, each will bring its own unique flavor and have guests streaming in! Happy cooking!

Recipe