Cake pops—you've seen them in specialty bakeries and even some coffee shops. They are sweet little treats aptly described as cake on a stick.
How hard is it to make your own? With the use of cake pop molds, it can be quite simple! I had never used these before, so I had to learn what to do from scratch, and all of these were super easy to use to create delicious cake pops.
I looked at a variety of different types and styles and ended up trying out six for myself, which I've reviewed below. So, read on for the lowdown on the best molds to try for simple desserts out of your own oven.
Jump to:
Top Cake Pop Mold Choices
- Best Cake Pop Mold Kit: Nice Kitchen Cake Pop Maker Kit
- Best Square Cake Pop Molds: AIERSA Square Cake Pop Mold Silicone
- Best Round Cake Pop Molds: Tosnail 2-Pack of 20 Silicone Cake Pop Mold
- Best Push Pop Cake Pop Molds: ihomecooker 20 Hole Push Pop Cake Stand and Pop Shooter Containers
- Best Cake Pop Baker Molds: Babycakes CP-12 Cake Pop Maker
- Best No-Bake Cake Pop Molds: Sweet Creations Round Cake Pop Press Mold
Each Cake Pop Mold Tested
1. Nice Kitchen Cake Pop Maker Kit: Best Cake Pop Mold Kit
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Pink Material: Silicone Number of Pieces Included: 9 Care Instructions: Safe for use in the oven, dishwasher, freezer, refrigerator and microwave |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + A full kit - everything you need + 3-tier stand for displaying the cake pops + Packaging materials for easy transport or gifting |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - The middle pops weren't quite compact enough |
Overall Impression: This was a really nice, comprehensive kit with everything you would need to make cake pops. It included two sets of 20 round molds, cake pop sticks, silicone cupcake holders, a cup to melt chocolate in, baggies with twist ties, a decorating "pen" with different tips, and a three-tier holder with a hole for each cake pop stick.
Performance: This was fun enough that my husband and kids got involved in the making of the cake pops. I sprayed the molds with cooking spray, put the batter in, and baked them for about 13 minutes. I will say these pops didn't come out very compact, particularly in the middle molds; I think maybe putting something on top to prevent them from rising so much would have helped.
User-Friendly Features: Everything about this was fun and easy to use. You could put the pops in the cupcake liners instead of on a cake pop stick if desired, and the packaging materials, made it easy to transport the cake pops.
2. AIERSA Square Cake Pop Mold Silicone: Best Square Cake Pop Molds
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Orange Material: Silicone Number of Pieces Included: 2 Care Instructions: Microwave, oven, freezer and dishwasher safe |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + Square cake pops looked cool + Easy to remove cake if cooking spray is used |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - Cake is hard to remove if you don't use spray |
Overall Impression: I was quite pleased with these and liked the idea of having cube-shaped cake pops. The kit came with two molds with room for 15 square pops each.
Performance: These worked better than I expected, but you definitely need to spray with cooking spray. I tried both with and without spray and when I didn't use it, the cake stuck to the molds.
With nothing on top of the mold to contain the cake, the tops puffed up, but it was easy to cut the tops off before even removing the pops from the molds. Note that these pops were also not very compact, making them a bit difficult to dip or frost.
User-Friendly Features: These are easy to use and easy to remove excess cake from the top.
3. Tosnail 2-Pack of 20 Silicone Cake Pop Mold: Best Round Cake Pop Molds
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Pink Material: Silicone Number of Pieces Included: 2 Shape: Rectangular Care Instructions: Safe for use in the oven, freezer, and microwave |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + Easy to use + Inexpensive |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - Pops in the middle aren't quite compact enough for easy frosting |
Overall Impression: These were the same cake pop molds used in the kit described above. They were the same color and had the same flexibility. They come with just the molds themselves, making them a budget-friendly option or a great replacement for the kit if the molds need to be replaced.
Performance: These performed the same as the ones in the kit; the cake pops in the outside molds were more compact than the ones in the middle.
User-Friendly Features: These are easy to use and easy to pop the cake out of. I did use cooking spray to make it easier to take the pops out without sticking.
4. ihomecooker 20 Hole Push Pop Cake Stand and Pop Shooter Containers: Best Push Pop Cake Pop Molds
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Clear Material: Plastioc Number of Pieces Included: 2 Shape: Round Product Dimensions: 9.9"L x 8.4"W x 3.4"H |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + Makes an impressive-looking dessert + Can make a variety of different items with these + Easy to clean |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - Took a few minutes to figure out what to do - Came with no instructions |
Overall Impression: These looked pretty cool and I was looking forward to making desserts similar to those you might get at a restaurant. You use the stick at the bottom to push up the cake.
Performance: These worked very well once I got the hang of them. I baked a thin layer of cake, then used the cake pop mold as a cutter to fill it with a layer of cake. Then I added a layer of frosting or melted chocolate, then repeated until it was as full as I wanted it.
User-Friendly Features: This had a bit of a learning curve, but within a few minutes, it was easy enough. They were easy to clean and kept small fingers clean as my young relatives enjoyed their cake pops.
5. Babycakes CP-12 Cake Pop Maker: Best Cake Pop Baker Molds
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Purple Material: Plastic Product Dimensions: 8.07"D x 9.84"W x 4.72"H Special Feature: Nonstick |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + No need to use the oven + Fast and easy way of making cake pops + Easy to clean |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - No cons |
Overall Impression: This is similar to a waffle iron in that you pour the cake batter into the molds and let them cook in the machine for about 5 minutes, then remove them. You don't need to deal with preheating and baking the pops in the oven, which is nice in the summer.
Performance: This was fun and easy to use. At first, I tried using a spoon to fill the wells, but the first ones were starting to cook by the time I got to the last ones, so I switched to a pastry bag, and that worked much better. These cooked up nice and compact, which made them perfect for dipping.
User-Friendly Features: This preheated in just a few minutes and cooked the cake in 5 minutes. The pops came out cleanly, and the iron part just needed to be wiped down afterwards.
6. Sweet Creations Round Cake Pop Press Mold: Best No-Bake Cake Pop Molds
| SPECIFICATIONS | Color: Pink Material: Plastic Number of Pieces: 1 Product Dimensions: 8.11 x 4.96 x 1.65 inches |
| TODAY'S BEST DEALS | View at Amazon |
| REASONS TO BUY | + Very simple to use + No baking required + Inexpensive |
| REASONS TO AVOID | - Makes only 5 cake pops at a time |
Overall Impression: This is a budget-friendly option for those who want to use pre-made cake to make cake pops in a matter of minutes.
Performance: This no-bake cake pop mold is super simple to use. Simply crush up cake and frosting, roll into a ball by hand, and fill up the molds. Press it closed, then remove any excess cake.
Dip cake pop sticks (included) in melted chocolate, then stick them through the holes of the mold into the pop. Let cool, and voila, you have nice, moist pops. The mold did get a bit messy, but it was easy to clean.
User-Friendly Features: This was very user-friendly and required no learning curve at all. It made nice pops and cleaned up nicely.
Factors to Consider When Purchasing a Cake Pop Mold
Bake vs. No-Bake
With many cake pop moles, you'll need to fill them with batter and bake them, allowing the cake to fill the molds. With others, though, you form the balls out of pre-baked cake and moisten it with frosting.
Still, others will bake the round cake pops for you. Consider which type you'd rather have.
Shape and Size
While you might picture the types of pops that come out of a round cake pop mold, there are also square cake pops. In addition, there are pops you can make in the shape of a rose or seasonal shapes.
Kit vs. Just the Molds
If you'll be wanting a display rack, the lollipop sticks, and baggies with twist-ties for packaging your cake pops, you might want a full kit.
If you will be serving your pops in cupcake liners or already have a kit and just need a refill on the molds themselves, you would probably want simply the pop molds.
Material
Many cake pop molds are made of silicone; others are made from plastic. While some people won't have a preference, others will so keep it in mind if you'd like to choose the construction of your cake pop mold.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a cake pop mold dishwasher safe?
If your cake pop mold is made from silicone, chances are good that it's dishwasher-safe on the top rack. Plastic molds are also likely safe.
The type that bakes the cake within the mold is normally not able to be put in the dishwasher. Read the manufacturer's instructions to be sure.
Do you need to bake the cake to use in a cake pop mold?
If you're using a mold where you add batter and they fill the round or square mold, you'll be baking the cake as you make the pops.
If you're using a mold where you use pre-baked cake to mold the pops, though, you can either bake the cake yourself or purchase a cake from a bakery or a grocery store.
How can I prevent the cake pops from sticking to the mold?
Many cake pop molds are non-stick, but it makes sense to spritz your molds with cooking spray to make it easier to slide them out.
When I used mine, the square ones definitely needed the spray, whereas the round ones did not. Better safe than sticky, though, so I'd recommend using it.
Can I cook other items in cake pop molds?
You can use your cake pop molds to make baked goods like brownie bites, savory cheesy dough bites, cookie dough balls, or chocolate truffles.
You could also use them to make small meatballs. Be sure anything you bake is completely cooked through before serving.
Finding the Best Cake Pop Molds for You
Choosing the best cake pop mold is a matter of thinking about what your goal is. If you're planning to make just a few pops for your family after dinner once in a while, you might prefer a simple round mold with a relatively small number of wells for the pops.
If you're planning to serve cake pops at a party, you might want a cake pop mold that can make a few dozen pops at once. In this case, a full kit along with some extra molds will give you lots of versatility.
The choice is really yours, and whatever you choose will bring you lots of joy as you bake and decorate your cake pops to enjoy on your own or share with others!
You Might Also Like:
Best Spatulas for Your Home Kitchen
Leave a Reply