10 Best Cardamom Substitutes to Use at Home

If you're looking for a cardamom substitute to enhance the flavor of your dishes, then you've come to the right place. Cardamom, a fragrant seasoning used in culinary creations for many years, can provide an intriguing flavor to any meal. 

In this article, I’ll explore the many facets of cardamom and its potential substitutes, covering common uses in cooking, its benefits, and ten great alternatives should it be unavailable or too expensive. So let's get started.

Jump to:

• Understanding Cardamom
• Best Cardamom Spice Substitutes
• Bonus Cardamom Substitutes
• Cardamom Substitute FAQs
• What Can I Substitute for Cardamom?
• Recipe

Understanding Cardamom

Cardamom, a widely-used spice in many savory dishes and sweet recipes, has an intricate flavor profile that cannot be easily substituted. It has a complex flavor profile that can be difficult to replicate with other spices.

Black cardamom (Amomum Subulatum) and green cardamom (Elettaria Cardamomum) are two types of the aromatic spice.

1. Green cardamom

Green cardamom is the most common type of cardamom employed in cooking, featuring a milder flavor than its black counterpart, and can be procured either whole or powdered. 

It has a milder taste than black cardamom and can be found whole or ground into powder form. Green cardamom is commonly used in savory dishes like curries, as well as sweet dishes such as apple pie spice blend.

Fun fact: White cardamom is just the bleached version of green cardamom pods.

2. Black cardamom

Black cardamom has a much more intense flavor than its green counterpart, and it’s usually sold in pods or seeds rather than the powdered form. Black Cardamom also contains aniseed-like notes, which make it great for adding depth to seafood dishes or meaty stews.

Both types of cardamom have health benefits, too. They contain antioxidants that help fight off free radicals that cause cell damage, reduce inflammation, improve digestion, boost immunity, aid weight loss, lower cholesterol levels, and even act as an anti-cancer agent.

Understanding cardamom is an important part of any chef's spice cabinet. Cardamom's distinctive taste and scent make it a great addition to many recipes. Now that you understand the basics of cardamom, let's explore some great substitutes for this aromatic spice.

Best Cardamom Spice Substitutes

Substituting cardamom can be a tricky business. It’s an aromatic spice with a unique flavor that is difficult to replicate but not impossible.

1. Allspice

This warm and fragrant spice has hints of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves all in one. While it won’t provide the same floral notes as cardamom, this substitute for cardamom spice will add depth of flavor to any dish that calls for this Middle Eastern staple.

Best for: baking with spice or apple pie spice, stews, and marinades

2. Cinnamon

With its sweet yet spicy taste, cinnamon makes a great cardamom substitute when used in small amounts—just don’t overdo it! It pairs well with other spices like ginger and nutmeg, so you can create your own blend for maximum flavor impact without overpowering the dish.

Best for: baking with spice or apple pie spice

3. Cloves

These tiny buds have a strong aroma and pungent taste, making them perfect for adding warmth and sweetness to dishes where you usually use cardamom—think curries or chai tea lattes!

Just remember that they are much more potent than their green counterpart, so use them sparingly if substituting them directly into recipes calling for cardamom specifically.

Best for: spice blends, baked goods, and savory dishes

4. Nutmeg

Another warming spice with sweet undertones, nutmeg is often used as a substitute for cardamom powder in baking recipes such as cakes or cookies. This good cardamom substitute has a milder flavor and won't overpower other ingredients too much—just be sure not to go overboard on the quantity!

Best for: spice blends, baked goods, and savory dishes 

5. Ginger

Aromatic ginger adds heat along with some subtle sweetness, making it ideal as a ground and whole cardamom pods substitute, depending on what type of recipe you're working with.

Just bear in mind that fresh root ginger will need pre-cooking before being added to dishes, whereas the dried powder form can usually be stirred straight in without any preparation required first!

Best for: baked goods, savory dishes, and spice blends

6. Coriander Seeds

These seeds have citrusy undertones, which make them great as a substitute for cardamom pods. Instead of ground cardamom, simply toast lightly before grinding up into powder form if desired (or leave whole). 

Then, stir through your dish at the end stages of the cooking process once everything else has been cooked through already. Otherwise, their delicate flavors may get lost amongst stronger-tasting ingredients during longer simmer times.

Best for: spice blends, marinades, and savory dishes

7. Aniseed

Aniseed provides similar licorice-like tones found within cardamom; however, its flavor profile tends to be slightly sweeter than its Middle Eastern cousin.

Adjust quantities accordingly when substituting directly into recipes calling out specifically either ingredient type only (no mixing together!).

Best for: cakes, cookies, breads, and savory dishes like stews and curries

8. Fennel Seeds

Not quite as intense as aniseed but still providing those distinctive licorice tones, fennel seeds work well alongside other spices such as cumin and coriander, bringing additional earthy elements. 

This helps round off overall flavors nicely. Again, you need to keep portions smaller than average since they are stronger than the regular cardamom typically seen in most traditional Indian and Asian cuisines.

Best for: spice blends, desserts, and savory dishes

9. Mace Blades

Mace blades, the outer covering from nutmegs, offer another viable option worth considering when looking at alternatives. This cardamom spice substitute tends to have more bitterness than sweetness, so adjust ratios accordingly based on your taste and preferences.

Best for: curries, stews, and other savory dishes or cakes, cookies, and pies

10. Star Anise

Last but by no means least, star anise brings another layer of complexity thanks largely due to its distinct licorice aromas combined with slight peppery afternotes. This great cardamom substitute is stronger and has a more dominant flavor, so it should be used in smaller quantities. 

Plus, there are always bonus points awarded whenever star-shaped items appear on dinner plates, right?

Best for: both sweet and savory dishes

💡Key Takeaway: Cardamom is a highly sought-after flavoring agent, offering an exclusive taste and aroma to recipes from all over. As such, it can be difficult to replicate its taste without access to or availability of this ingredient. 

Luckily, some great alternatives, such as ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg, offer distinct flavors that may do the trick. With proper knowledge of each one's characteristics, you can successfully recreate any dish with these substitutions.

Bonus Cardamom Substitutes

11. White Pepper Powder

White Pepper Powder is an excellent black cardamom substitute for those seeking something subtly spicy yet still able to maintain balance within their recipes by providing just enough kick without going overboard on heat levels.

12. Turmeric Powder

This bright yellow powder is a green cardamom substitute that offers mild yet distinct earthy undertones. This makes it ideal for curries or other Indian-inspired dishes where traditional flavors are desired without overwhelming them completely. 

Just remember, turmeric won't provide any real “heat”, so adjust accordingly based on personal preference!

Cardamom Substitute FAQs

Comprehending the nuances of spices can be a perplexing task, particularly when attempting to exchange one for another. Here are some answers to frequently asked questions about substituting cardamom in recipes.

1. How do you combine different spices as a substitute for cardamom?

When substituting other spices for cardamom, it’s important to consider the overall flavor profile of your dish. If you're seeking a flavor and scent similar to cardamom, think about ingredients such as cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, or allspice that offer warm flavors like the former.

Combining two or more of these will help create an even closer approximation than using just one alone.

For example, combining equal parts ground ginger and nutmeg creates an earthy blend with hints of sweetness that works well as a ground cardamom substitute in many recipes such as curries or desserts like rice pudding or apple pie filling.

2. What are some spice blends that work well as cardamom substitutes?

For those looking for convenience without sacrificing flavor quality, there are several pre-mixed blends available on the market which make a great substitute for ground cardamom. 

These include garam masala (a mix of coriander seed, cumin seed, black pepper, and cloves), Chinese five-spice powder (star aniseed combined with Szechuan peppercorns), or zaatar (a Middle Eastern mix containing thyme leaves). 

All three offer complex flavors reminiscent of what would be achieved by adding individual ingredients separately but require less time spent measuring out amounts and blending them together yourself—perfect if you're short on time.

3. Is cardamom important in a recipe?

Cardamom is an important ingredient in many recipes. It adds an unmistakable taste to both sweet and savory recipes, making it a great way to add depth of flavor.

Cardamom also provides numerous health benefits such as aiding digestion, reducing inflammation, and helping with respiratory issues. When used correctly, cardamom can be an essential part of creating delicious meals.

💡Key Takeaway: Combining spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, or allspice can be used to mimic the warm notes of cardamom in dishes. Alternatively, pre-mixed spice blends such as garam masala, Chinese five-spice powder, and zaatar are great timesaving alternatives that provide similar flavor profiles without sacrificing quality.

What Can I Substitute for Cardamom?

Cardamom is a multifaceted spice that can be employed in both sweet and savory recipes. While it is an expensive spice, there are some cardamom alternatives if you don't have any on hand.

From ginger to allspice, each alternative brings its own distinct taste and aroma. Trying out a variety of mixtures will assist you in uncovering the ideal blend for your dish. Whether you're looking for an exact replacement or just something close enough, these 10 best cardamom substitutes have got you covered.

Whether you are cooking savory meat dishes or baking sweet treats like apple pies, having a good understanding of what spices work well together can help take your culinary skills to the next level.

Discover delicious recipes and learn how to use cardamom substitutes in your cooking with Also the Crumbs. Explore our buying guides and air fryer-friendly tips for a healthier lifestyle today!

Recipe