Finding the perfect liquid smoke substitute can't be that hard, right? After all, it's only a substitute for real smoke!But unless you're planning to cook over coals or make your own liquid smoke, you'll need a kitchen staple that can swap in easily. You've probably considered smoked paprika, but I'm here to show you that there are several creative options to impart that pure smoke flavor.
Jump to:
What is Liquid Smoke?
Liquid smoke is a concentrated form of smoke used to flavor food with a smoky taste without traditional smoking methods. Concerns about its safety have led people to seek alternatives that provide authentic smokiness while maintaining convenience in their recipes.
According to Eater, liquid smoke was invented by Ernest H. Wright in 1895 when he discovered that passing wood fumes through water resulted in a flavorful solution. This innovative method allowed cooks to add an intense smoky flavor without using a natural wood fire or burning wood chips.Today's commercial liquid smoke products are made by condensing these vapors into a fine powder or concentrate before being dissolved in water.
The Invention and Production of Liquid Smoke
Liquid smoke was invented by Ernest H. Wright in 1895 when he discovered that passing wood fumes through water resulted in a flavorful solution. This innovative method allowed cooks to add an intense smoky flavor without using natural wood fire or burning wood chips.
Today's commercial liquid smoke products are made by condensing these vapors into a fine powder or concentrate before being dissolved in water.
The 6 Best Liquid Smoke Substitutes
Desperate for that smoked flavor and don't know where to turn? I've got you.
Finding the best recipe substitutions for home cooks is my passion. One missing ingredient should never doom a delicious dish!These are my top 6 liquid smoke alternatives for every occasion.
1. Smoked Paprika
Smoked paprika, also known as pimenton de la Vera or Spanish smoked paprika, is a versatile spice made from dried and ground red bell peppers that have been traditionally smoked over oak wood fires.
It's among the most popular substitutes for liquid smoke because it adds a sweet, smoky flavor and vibrant color to dishes like paella or barbecue rubs. Use it in place of liquid smoke by starting with ¼ teaspoon per recipe serving and adjusting according to taste.
Best for: Smoked paprika is fantastic at imparting extra flavor to smoked meats, barbecue rubs, and heavy tomato sauces. You can also use smoked paprika to spice up a luscious San Marzano pizza sauce.
Its natural smokiness and deep, sweet flavor fit neatly into the Italian, Mexican, Southern US, and Spanish flavor palates: try it in a seafood paella!
RELATED: What is the Best Smoked Paprika Substitute?
2. Chipotle Powder
Chipotle powder is made from dried jalapeno peppers that have been slowly smoked over a natural wood fire. This fine powder imparts a hot, smoky flavor perfect for adding depth to chili or ground beef burritos.
It's a classic choice in Southern cuisine and Tex-Mex. I'm a huge fan of using chipotle powder in barbecue rubs and then doubling up by adding it to a spicy, tangy, smoky barbecue sauce.
Begin with ⅛ teaspoon per serving when substituting for liquid smoke, and adjust the amount based on your desired heat level. Powdered chipotle varies significantly in heat intensity, so you'll need to taste and adjust according to how hot you want the dish.
Best for: Chipotle powder is the perfect barbecue rub spice. It complements smoked meat and meaty sauces to enjoy with rice or pasta, but it's also superb in vegan recipes—try adding it to a vegan chili or roasted bell peppers.
3. Canned Chipotle Peppers
Another option for adding smokiness is using canned chipotle peppers in adobo sauce. These are smoked jalapeno peppers packed in a tangy, spicy sauce.
Chop the peppers and add them to your recipe for an intense smoky flavor with a kick of heat. Start with one pepper per serving and adjust according to taste.
Best for: Canned chipotle peppers are a fantastic choice for a duck adobo; they bring a smoky richness that suits the fatty duck perfectly. They're great in pork and beef adobo and other hearty, meaty stews for the same reason. You can also try them in chili and vegan stews.
RELATED: The Adobo Sauce Substitute List You Can Trust
4. Smoked Tea
Lapsang Souchong, a Chinese black tea, is smoked over pine fires during processing, giving it a unique smoky aroma and taste.
To use this as a liquid smoke substitute, steep 1 teaspoon of loose-leaf tea or one teabag in boiling water for five minutes before adding it to your dish. This method works best in recipes that call for added liquid, like soups or stews.
Best for: Smoked tea adds a delicious, unique touch to sweet desserts like marzipan fruitcake and chocolate mousse. It's also amazing with seafood dishes—consider using it with steamed clams or steamed white fish recipes.
5. Smoked Salt
Smoked salt is sea salt that has been cold-smoked over wood fires, such as hickory or mesquite, imparting an earthy smokiness ideal for seasoning meats or vegetables without overpowering other flavors.
Replace regular salt with smoked salt in equal amounts when substituting liquid smoke in recipes.
Best for: Smoked salt is extremely versatile—simply replace the usual salt content with the smoked version! It's a natural choice for barbecue seasoning, grilled flank steak or skirt steak, baked fish, and air fryer chicken kabobs.
6. Hickory Smoke Powder
A concentrated form of natural wood fire smoke made from burning hickory chips can be found as a hickory smoke powder. Hickory is a popular wood for smoking meat, as explained by Bon Appetit.
It adds an authentic barbecue-like essence to dishes without the need for grilling or smoking methods.
Use sparingly—start by adding just ⅛ teaspoon per serving and adjusting based on preference.
These popular liquid smoke substitutes can be used to add a smoky flavor without having to use actual liquid smoke. You're ready to create delicious recipes that call for a smoky taste!
Best for: Hickory smoke powder helps you achieve that unique smoked flavor without the grill. Air fryer hamburger patties really benefit here and pan-seared steaks and blackened salmon are also natural choices.
5 Dishes to Try With Substitutes for Liquid Smoke
Many dishes can benefit from the addition of a smoky flavor using liquid smoke substitutes instead of traditional smoking methods or relying on potentially harmful ingredients like PAHs found in some brands of liquid products.
Below, I’ll list some recipes that commonly call for these substitutes, along with descriptions regarding consistency, flavor, and how to use them within each dish accordingly.
1. BBQ Pulled Pork
A BBQ pulled pork recipe is an excellent choice for incorporating a liquid smoke alternative such as smoked paprika or chipotle powder.
The intense smoky flavor complements the tangy barbecue sauce while adding depth to the overall taste profile. Simply mix your preferred substitute into the sauce before cooking to achieve a deliciously smoky result.
2. Vegan Chili
Vegan chili, made with beans and vegetables, benefits greatly from added smokiness through alternatives like smoked paprika or canned chipotle peppers. Smoked bacon isn't an option here!Add either ingredient during the sautéing process to infuse your chili with rich, natural wood fire flavors without overpowering other spices present in the dish.
3. Green Bean Casserole
A delicious air fryer green bean casserole can be upgraded by using Spanish smoked paprika or hickory smoke powder as a liquid smoke alternative.Stir your chosen substitute into the casserole and adjust to taste, ensuring a smoky aroma without overpowering sweetness.
4. Vegetarian Stuffed Peppers
Enhance vegetarian stuffed peppers with a smoky twist by adding smoked paprika or chipotle powder to the filling mixture.
The addition of these substitutes will provide an extra layer of flavor complexity while still allowing the natural flavors of vegetables and grains to shine through.
5. White Bean Soup
A warm bowl of white bean soup featuring cannellini beans, kale, and tomatoes can be elevated with liquid smoke alternatives like smoked tea or finely powdered charcoal for a subtle hint of smokiness that complements its hearty ingredients perfectly.
Tips for Substituting Liquid Smoke in Recipes
When substituting liquid smoke alternatives, it's essential to consider how the smoky element is being utilized and adjust accordingly.
I’ll provide tips on choosing the right substitute based on desired heat levels, flavor intensity, and cooking methods while maintaining a balance between smokiness and other flavors.
Matching Substitutes with Intended Recipe Outcomes
The first step in selecting an appropriate liquid smoke replacement is understanding your desired outcome. For instance, smoked paprika would be an excellent choice if you want a sweet, smoky flavor without any added heat.
For a hot, smoky taste with some spiciness, chipotle powder or canned chipotle may be an ideal choice.
Adjusting Quantities of Substitutes for Optimal Flavor Balance
- Smoked Paprika: Start with 1 teaspoon per pound of meat or vegetables as a dry rub or seasoning mix ingredient. Adjust according to taste preferences.
- Hickory Smoke Powder: Use sparingly - about ¼ teaspoon per pound of food should suffice since this fine powder has an intense smoky aroma that can overpower other flavors if used excessively.
- Canned Chipotle Peppers: Add one pepper at a time until you reach your preferred level of spice; remember that these peppers pack quite a punch.
Experimenting with Alternatives to Suit Your Personal Preferences
No two palates are alike. What may work well for one person might not suit another's tastes perfectly. Don't be afraid to try different liquid smoke alternatives and combinations until you find the perfect balance of smokiness, heat, and flavor for your specific preferences.
For example, you could experiment with using smoked salt in place of regular salt or combining smoked tea with other spices to create a unique dry rub.
Remember that cooking is an art form—feel free to get creative and make adjustments as needed based on personal taste preferences.
By following these tips and experimenting with various liquid smoke substitutes, you can achieve deliciously smoky dishes without relying on potentially harmful ingredients found in some brands of liquid products.
With the right combination of substitutes and adjusted quantities, you can achieve a smoky flavor in your recipes without using liquid smoke.
Liquid Smoke Substitute FAQs
Yes, there are several substitutions for liquid smoke. Some popular alternatives include smoked paprika, chipotle powder, canned chipotle peppers, smoked tea, smoked salt, and hickory smoke powder. These substitutes can provide a smoky flavor to your dishes without using liquid smoke..
To replace 1 teaspoon of liquid smoke in recipes, you can use ½ to 1 teaspoon of smoked paprika or chipotle powder. You also have the option to use one canned chipotle pepper or approximately one tablespoon of brewed smoked tea. Adjust the quantities according to taste preferences and the desired level of smokiness.
Liquid smoke has been associated with safety concerns due to the presence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which have carcinogenic properties. However, the levels found in commercial products are generally low and considered safe when consumed in moderation. For those who prefer avoiding it altogether, alternatives are available.
If substituting with smoked paprika instead of using liquid smoke in a recipe that calls for it as an ingredient, start by adding about half (½) teaspoon per every full (1) teaspoon required by the original recipe. Adjust accordingly based on personal preference regarding intensity and overall balance within the dish's flavors.
Smokin' Hot Substitutes for Flavorful Dishes
You don't need a bottle of the smoky stuff or fancy tools like a smoke gun to get that unique taste.
All you need is a few kitchen essentials and some creativity.You've got it all—now raise your game by infusing your favorite savory dishes with delicious smoky flavors!
Recipe
Best Liquid Smoke Substitutes
Ingredients
- ¼ teaspoon smoked paprika
- ⅛ teaspoon chipotle powder
- ½ teaspoon smoked salt (to taste)
Instructions
Smoked Paprika
- Replace each drop of liquid smoke with ¼ teaspoon of smoked paprika. Adjust to taste.
Chipotle Powder
- You can swap out a drop of liquid smoke for ⅛ teaspoon of dried chipotle powder. Adjust carefully, as some chipotle powder is quite strong.
Smoked Salt
- Replace the regular salt in the recipe with smoked salt in a 1:1 ratio. If the recipe is very salty, consider using equal parts regular and smoked salt to prevent overpowering it with a smoky flavor.
Notes
You can find the video in the post above. If you don't see a video, please check your browser settings.
Leave a Reply