Best Piquillo Pepper Substitutes for Every Dish

Navigating the world of peppers, I've often found myself searching for the perfect piquillo pepper substitute. Piquillo peppers, with their distinct sweet and slightly spicy taste, hold a special place in many dishes.

But what happens when they're not available, or you simply want to try something new? Fear not, fellow culinary enthusiasts.

Whether you're whipping up a Spanish tapa or a gourmet creation of your own, there are substitutes ready to elevate your dish.

Join me as I embark on a flavorful journey to discover alternatives that not only match but sometimes even enhance the original taste profile.

Jump to:

• The Piquillo Pepper: A Culinary Gem from Spain
• Best Piquillo Peppers
• Helpful Tips on Substituting Piquillo Peppers
• Piquillo Pepper Substitute FAQs
• Recipe

The Piquillo Pepper: A Culinary Gem from Spain

Have you ever encountered the piquillo pepper in your culinary adventures? This distinctive and flavorful ingredient hails from Northern Spain, earning a place among popular peppers worldwide.

This unique blend of flavors makes them incredibly versatile in cooking, as they can complement many different ingredients without overpowering them.

Purchasing and Preparing Piquillos

You'll typically find these small red peppers jarred after being roasted and peeled. The roasting process enhances their natural sweetness while adding depth of flavor with subtle smoky notes. 

Higher-end supermarkets or specialty stores catering to gourmet food enthusiasts are likely spots where you might locate these culinary gems.

Culinary Uses of the Versatile Piquillos

Beyond their delicious taste, piquillos shine because of their adaptability across various dishes globally. Whether eaten raw or cooked, they enhance flavors due to an interesting combination—sweet meets tart elements coupled with underlying smokiness.

Best Piquillo Peppers

Piquillo peppers are a culinary delight with their unique flavor profile. But what happens when you can't find these Spanish gems? The answer is simple—turn to substitutes that will still give your dishes the delicious results they deserve.

1. Roasted Bell Peppers

Bell peppers, known for their sweet and mild flavor, become a culinary delight when roasted. To use them as a piquillo pepper substitute, opt for the red variety for a closer match in taste. 

Depending on the size of the dish, replace one piquillo pepper with half a roasted bell pepper. While they might not have the same mild heat, they compensate with a smoky depth that can truly enrich a recipe.

Best for stuffed peppers, paellas, and salads.

2. Jalapeno Peppers

Jalapeno peppers are a bit of a wild card in this list. They bring a spicier kick compared to the mild heat of piquillo peppers.

To substitute piquillos with jalapenos, I'd suggest using them sparingly—perhaps start with half a jalapeno for every piquillo pepper in the recipe. It's crucial to taste and adjust as you go.

Best for dishes that can benefit from a little extra heat, like salsas, tapenades, and certain meat marinades.

3. Cherry Peppers

Cherry peppers are small, round, and pack a flavorful punch, combining both sweet and spicy notes.

When substituting for piquillo peppers, use them in a one-to-one ratio. The tanginess they bring can often elevate a dish, making it both familiar and refreshingly new.

Best for dishes where the pepper is a centerpiece, like pickled appetizers, atop pizzas, or even in salads. 

4. Banana Peppers

Elongated and light yellow, banana peppers are known for their mild and tangy flavor.

When searching for a piquillo substitute, you can use banana peppers in a one-to-one ratio. However, keep in mind they have a distinct tang that might influence the overall flavor profile. 

Their delicate heat complements dishes that benefit from a subtle pepper presence.

Best for sandwiches, salads, and even as a garnish on pizzas. 

5. Roasted Fresno Pepper

Roasted Fresno peppers are a delightful ingredient with a moderate heat level, closer to jalapenos than piquillos. When you roast them, their sweetness is amplified, making them a worthy contender for piquillo substitution.

Replace each piquillo pepper with three-quarters of a roasted Fresno pepper, and adjust according to your heat preference. Their unique flavor profile adds both heat and sweetness, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

Best for stews, chili dishes, and spicy dips. 

Helpful Tips on Substituting Piquillo Peppers

• Taste as you go: Different peppers have varying levels of heat and sweetness, so I suggest adjusting the amount based on your preference and the dish's requirements.
• Consider the dish's texture: Some substitutes may be juicier or crunchier than piquillo peppers. This can affect the overall feel of your dish.
• Remember the color: Piquillo peppers have a vibrant red hue; if the appearance of your dish is crucial, this is something not to forget.
• Don't be afraid to mix and match: Combining two different pepper substitutes can sometimes create a flavor profile that's close to or even better than the original.
• Roasting can change everything: Roasted versions of certain peppers bring out additional sweetness and depth, making them closer in flavor to piquillo peppers.

Piquillo Pepper Substitute FAQs

Exploring the realm of culinary substitutes is a testament to our adaptability and creativity in the kitchen.

While piquillo peppers have their own charm, the substitutes listed above can do more than just fill in—they can shine in their own right. I encourage you to try them out, mix things up, and redefine your dishes.

For more ingredient swap ideas and culinary tips, keep browsing our blog. And when you've given one of these substitutes a go, drop a comment. We'd love to hear about your flavorful adventures!

You Might Also Like:

Best Serrano Pepper Substitutes for Flavorful Dishes

What Is the Best Substitute for Cayenne Pepper in Your Kitchen?

7 Best White Pepper Substitutes for Flavorful Dishes

Recipe